Progress Residential and its owner, Pretium Partners, agreed to pay $49.75 million to settle charges from the Federal Trade Commission and four states over hidden rental fees, security deposit deductions and move-in conditions. The FTC called it "the largest enforcement matter taken against a landlord" in its history, according to its November 6, 2026 announcement. The order is still proposed: it takes effect only if a federal judge approves and signs it, and the companies deny wrongdoing.
You do not manage 90,000 homes. But the practices the regulators targeted, from add-on monthly fees to wear-and-tear deductions, show up in small and mid-size portfolios every day. This is the clearest picture yet of what federal and state enforcers expect a rental listing and a deposit return to look like.
What happened
The FTC, joined by Arizona, Colorado, Indiana and Utah, filed a complaint and a proposed stipulated order in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia. The Commission voted 2-0 to file. According to the FTC, Progress manages more than 90,000 homes in 17 states.
The money splits two ways under the proposed order: $48.5 million to the FTC for consumer redress and $1.25 million to Arizona. Indiana's attorney general announced the settlement a day earlier, describing the $48.5 million as relief for consumers nationwide.
These are allegations, not court findings. The regulators allege that Progress:
- Advertised monthly rents that left out mandatory monthly fees, including a "smart home" fee and a "utility management" fee, according to the FTC.
- Charged a poorly disclosed "renter's insurance exemption fee" when tenants did not show proof of renters' insurance, which many first saw on their first bill.
- Advertised homes as move-in ready and inspected, while many needed serious maintenance, repair or cleaning.
- Kept deposits for normal wear and tear, for conditions that existed before move-in, and for renovations that were the company's responsibility, and often did not send the itemized statement it promised.
- Used form contracts with nondisparagement clauses that barred negative comments about the company, and left billing and maintenance complaints unresolved while late fees piled up.
The FTC also notes the complaint says much of the conduct happened under prior management, and that new management has taken steps to address it. A company spokesperson told HousingWire the agreement "contains no admission of wrongdoing" and that its practices were consistent with industry practice.
Why it matters for property managers
The total-price rule is the headline. If the judge signs the order, Progress must advertise the "true total monthly rental price," including all mandatory recurring fees, more prominently than any other pricing. That order binds only Progress and Pretium. But the head of the FTC's consumer protection bureau said the agency will keep acting "where appropriate" in the rental market. And Indiana says it built its claims under its own state consumer protection laws, which, the office says, apply to every landlord doing business in Indiana.
This is the second big single-family case in two years. Invitation Homes agreed in 2024 to pay $48 million and change some practices. Two settlements of this size suggest enforcers have a playbook for rental fees.
Deposits are where small operators get hurt. The proposed order requires uniform standards for withholding deposits, staff training, condition records for each home, and an itemized statement of every deduction within 30 days of move-out or the timeline state law requires. Many states already set their own deposit deadlines and itemization rules. What is new is a federal regulator spelling out the process it expects.
Review gag clauses are a liability. The proposed order would bar Progress from requiring standardized nondisparagement clauses. If your lease template still has one, it is a cheap fix now and an expensive one later.
What to do this week
- Audit every live listing. Add up base rent plus every mandatory recurring fee (tech, trash, valet trash, pest, utility admin, amenity). If the advertised number is lower than what a tenant must pay each month, fix the listing so the full amount is clear.
- List every one-time and situational fee in one place. Application, admin, insurance-waiver or exemption, pet, late fees. Make sure each appears in the listing or pre-lease disclosure before an applicant commits, not on the first ledger.
- Tighten move-in condition reports. Date-stamped photos of every room at move-in and move-out. You cannot defend a deduction without a record of the starting condition.
- Check your deposit return deadline and itemization rules. They vary by state, so check your state's statute and confirm with local counsel. Stop deducting for normal wear and tear, pre-existing damage, or upgrades you chose to make.
- Strip nondisparagement or review clauses from lease templates and addenda.
- Set a response clock for billing disputes. Make sure a tenant disputing a fee can still pay undisputed rent, and do not let late fees run while a dispute sits unanswered.
What we're watching
- Court approval. The FTC says the proposed order will have the force of law only when the district court judge approves and signs it. Watch for that signature.
- Redress details. The proposed order directs how the $48.5 million in consumer redress is used. Tenants may ask your office about eligibility if you manage former Progress homes.
- More state action. Indiana's attorney general said the companies must also ensure tenants can dispute fees without losing the ability to pay rent. Expect state AGs to borrow these terms.
- Fee disclosure laws. If your state or city has its own rental fee disclosure rule, this case raises the odds it gets enforced.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Fee and deposit rules vary by state and city; confirm with local counsel before changing your practices.