New York's housing agency has rewritten the guidance at the center of a wave of rent-overcharge suits against owners of rent-stabilized buildings. In an update to Fact Sheet 40 published Nov. 16, 2026, the Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) says it "continues to recognize" distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents. The suits it bears on involve at least 21 cases, more than 24 properties and 12,000 units, according to law firm Adler & Stachenfeld.
The update does not end the litigation. It changes what tenants' lawyers have to prove, and it makes the paper trail behind each concession you granted far more important.
What happened
The dispute comes from 2019. The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act, signed June 14, 2019, requires an owner charging less than the legal regulated rent (a "preferential rent") to keep offering that lower rent on renewal, raised only by the guideline increase or a DHCR-approved increase. Several months later, DHCR removed an example from Fact Sheet 40 that had distinguished concessions from preferential rents, without explanation.
Before that, DHCR had treated a concession as distinct from a preferential rent when the free period did not exceed three months and the tenant paid the full monthly rent for the rest of the lease, according to Kucker Marino Winiarsky & Bittens. Many owners kept granting free months after 2019 and set renewal increases off the full lease rent, not the discounted net effective rent, per The Real Deal.
Tenants' lawyers argued that those concessions were really preferential rents, so every renewal priced off the full rent was an overcharge. Courts gave that argument weight, starting with a Manhattan trial-court decision known as Grey, per Bisnow, and several appellate decisions treated the 2019 edit as a change of guidance for post-HSTPA concessions, per Kucker Marino. Suits followed: one firm filed 21 such suits between August and early November, according to Adler & Stachenfeld data cited by Bisnow, and one suit claims AvalonBay overcharged Downtown Brooklyn tenants by at least $40 million. The targets have centered on 421a buildings, where even market-rate units can be rent-regulated during the abatement period, and Adler & Stachenfeld counts $1 billion in 421a tax credits received by the buildings involved.
The revised fact sheet now states that DHCR's 2019 modification "was not intended to indicate the contrary," as quoted by The Real Deal. A DHCR spokesperson added that each case is fact-specific and the agency will not pre-judge whether any particular concession is lawful.
Why it matters for property managers
The burden shifts to the facts. Landlord attorney Matthew Brett of Belkin Burden Goldman said whether a concession counts as a preferential rent depends on the circumstances when the lease was signed, such as building conditions, occupancy and how long the concession lasted, per The Real Deal. Another defense attorney told Bisnow that plaintiffs will now have to show the reasons for a concession did not exist when it was offered. That is a prediction from counsel, not a ruling.
Pending suits are not dismissed. Courts still have to decide how to apply the clarified guidance to individual cases, Propmodo notes, and one attorney told Bisnow he "very highly" doubts open litigation will stop. The fact sheet is agency guidance, not a statute or a court order.
421a exposure stays larger. In suits against 421a buildings, plaintiffs claim they can seek the property-tax benefits the owner received, not just the alleged overpayment, which raises the stakes compared with buildings that only carry rent-stabilized units, according to Adler & Stachenfeld's Zachary Nathanson.
Concessions are still a live tool, carefully. Owners often grant free months during lease-up, when a building's amenities aren't available yet, or in the slower winter leasing season, per Bisnow. The update suggests a concession tied to a documented reason can be defended. It does not say every concession is safe, and the agency said it would not pre-judge any case.
Outside New York, the lesson travels. Any regulated program that caps renewal increases off a base rent can turn a concession into a pricing question. If you manage affordable, tax-credit or locally rent-controlled units elsewhere, confirm with local counsel which rent your program treats as the base.
What to do this week
- Inventory every concession granted on a rent-stabilized or 421a unit since June 2019. List the unit, lease dates, free period, and the lease rent used as the base for each renewal.
- Rebuild the "why" file for each one. Pull what existed at signing: lease-up occupancy reports, construction schedules, amenity delays, market comps. Mr. Brett's comments point to these facts as the ones that matter.
- Check lease and rider language. Confirm each concession was written as a temporary discount on a stated lease rent, and how the renewal base was described. Have counsel review anything ambiguous.
- If you are already named in a suit, send the update to your litigation counsel today. Ask whether it supports a motion or a request to revisit prior rulings in your case.
- Set a rule for new concessions. Before granting free rent on a stabilized unit, record the business reason, the occupancy at the time and the term, and have it reviewed against current DHCR guidance.
- Flag it for owners and lenders. Uncertainty here had already begun affecting underwriting. Give owners and lenders a short note on your exposure and the documentation you hold.
What we're watching
- How courts treat the update. Landlord attorney Nativ Winiarsky said the word "continues" likely bodes well for asking courts to reconsider decisions such as Grey, per The Real Deal. The first rulings that cite the revised fact sheet will show whether it carries weight.
- The pace of new filings. Mr. Nathanson told Bisnow he wonders whether the update slows down the seeming acceleration of new cases.
- Further DHCR detail. DHCR says concessions may still count as preferential rents in some contexts, and one attorney said the new guidance leaves some ambiguity about those conditions. Any further agency guidance or a legislative fix would change the analysis.
This is general information, not legal advice. Rent-regulation outcomes turn on each lease's facts; confirm with New York counsel before changing renewal pricing on a regulated unit.