Free to start · unlimited unitsGet started free
Market trend4 min read

Rates must hit 5.5% for a home loan payment to match rent: what it means for renewals

RealPage finds owning a median home, with taxes and insurance, costs about $930 a month more than average rent, and 57% of renters renewed in Q3. With Freddie Mac's 30-year rate at 7.18%, expect high retention, but price renewals against your submarket.

By Proppely Research Desk3 sources cited

Owning a median-priced home now costs about $930 a month more than the average apartment rent once property taxes and insurance are included, according to a new RealPage analysis. By RealPage's math, mortgage rates would have to fall to about 5.5% before the loan payment alone matches rent, and Freddie Mac's 30-year average was still 7.18% on Nov. 5. For landlords, that gap is the main reason residents are renewing more and staying longer.

What happened

RealPage compared the monthly payment on a median-priced home (30-year fixed, 20% down) with average apartment rent at five points since 2000. Today the principal-and-interest payment runs about $2,300, roughly 20% above the $1,915 average rent in its data. Even near the 2006 housing peak, the payment ran only about 16% above rent.

Add national-average property taxes and insurance and the full cost of owning reaches about $2,840 a month. On that all-in basis, RealPage puts the break-even mortgage rate at about 2.7%, close to the pandemic-era record low. If rates stay put instead, the median home price would have to fall to about $351,000, roughly 16% below today, for the loan payment to match rent.

Renters are acting on that math. In RealPage data, 57% of renters with leases expiring in the third quarter of 2026 renewed, versus 46% in 2006, and the average renewal term is now a little over 12 months, the longest RealPage has recorded since 2002. The Northeast leads, with 64% of residents renewing in the third quarter.

Rates have eased a bit since RealPage ran its numbers. Freddie Mac's 30-year average slipped from 7.24% on Oct. 29 to 7.18% on Nov. 5, but that is still nearly a point above the 6.22% of a year earlier.

Why it matters for property managers

Retention is doing the heavy lifting. RealPage's October numbers show rents fell 0.7% in the month, the first monthly cut of 2026, and occupancy eased to 95%. RealPage notes that when fewer residents move out to buy, occupancy holds up better. That buys you fewer turns, fewer vacant days and lower make-ready spend.

The escape valve depends on where you operate. RealPage estimates the break-even rate is about 6% in the Midwest, where the median home sells for about $330,000, but about 4% in the West, where the median price tops $610,000. A Midwest portfolio is much closer to losing residents to ownership if rates drop than a West Coast one is. Note that the 6% figure covers the loan payment only, not taxes and insurance.

Staying is not the same as paying more. Residents who can't afford to buy are also stretched on rent. A renewal increase that is out of line with your submarket can push a resident to a cheaper apartment instead of a house. In October, rents were still falling year over year in markets such as Houston (-1.8%), Tampa (-1%) and Denver (-0.8%), so new-lease competition is real in parts of the Sun Belt and Mountain West even while national renewal rates are high.

This is an analysis, not a forecast. RealPage's break-even figures assume 20% down and national-average taxes and insurance, and leave out maintenance and tax deductions. Use them to frame your thinking, not as a prediction for any single property.

What to do this week

  1. Pull your own renewal rate and average renewal term by property for the last two quarters. Compare them with RealPage's 57% national renewal rate. If you are well below it, look at service and pricing before blaming the housing market.
  2. Price renewals against your submarket, not against "nowhere else to go." High retention gives you room for modest increases, but test each offer against current new-lease asking rents and concessions nearby.
  3. Offer longer terms where they fit your expiration schedule. Residents are already choosing longer leases. Use 13- to 15-month options to steer move-outs away from your slow leasing months.
  4. Rebudget turnover for 2027. If your move-outs are trending down, cut make-ready and vacancy-loss assumptions to match your actual data, and shift some of that budget to retention work such as maintenance response times.
  5. Set a rate alert. RealPage flags 5.5% as the first milestone. Track Freddie Mac's weekly average, and if it moves toward 6% and you operate in lower-priced markets, plan for the possibility of more move-outs to ownership.

What we're watching

  • The 10-year Treasury. RealPage notes mortgage rates track the 10-year more closely than the Fed's rate, and that the 10-year has eased from above 5.3% in early October to about 5% while mortgage rates stayed above 7%.
  • Freddie Mac's weekly survey. A sustained move under 7% would be the first step toward the break-even zone, not arrival at it.
  • Home prices. Even modest declines, combined with income growth, narrow the gap over time. RealPage estimates it would take about eight years of typical income growth at today's prices and rates for the payment to fall back to 25% of median income.
  • Renewal and lease-length data. If both keep rising, residents are settling in for the long haul, and your 2027 plan should assume it.

Questions managers are asking

What mortgage rate would make buying a home as cheap as renting?

RealPage estimates the 30-year rate would need to fall to about 5.5% for the loan payment on a median-priced home to match average apartment rent. Including property taxes and insurance, the break-even rate drops to about 2.7%.

How many renters are renewing their leases in 2026?

In RealPage data, 57% of renters whose leases expired in the third quarter of 2026 renewed, compared with 46% in 2006. The Northeast led at 64%.

What is the current 30-year mortgage rate?

Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.18% as of Nov. 5, 2026, down from 7.24% the week before and up from 6.22% a year earlier.

Sources

Every figure in this briefing traces back to one of these reports.

  1. 01
  2. 02
  3. 03

Turn the briefing into this week’s work.

Proppely runs leases, rent, maintenance and accounting for landlords and property managers — with an AI that already reads this desk.

Keep reading

More from the desk

All briefings