A three-story mixed-use building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn collapsed into the excavation next door on Wednesday afternoon, and New York City's mayor said eight people were killed, including two construction workers. The official cause has not yet been identified, but city records show the neighboring jobsite had already drawn stop-work orders over protection of surrounding properties. If you own or manage an older building next to a hole in the ground, this is the week to check what your neighbor's contractor owes you and what you owe your own residents.
What happened
The building at 1321 Flatbush fell into a hole at the development site at 2625 Bedford Avenue, where excavation began in September of this year. At least 17 people were injured as of Thursday morning.
The jobsite's record before the collapse, according to the Department of Buildings and city records:
- On March 20, DOB issued a stop-work order and a violation during demolition after inspectors found inadequate overhead protection for some surrounding properties.
- On April 23, inspectors found demolition had resumed under the order, which brought another violation. City records show a $10,000 fine was issued.
- In May, an inspector issued further citations and another stop-work order, including for allegedly failing to protect neighboring buildings and deviating from approved plans. Realtor.com reports the city lifted that order within a week. DOB separately told Construction Dive it lifted the March stop-work order on May 8 after the project team corrected the violating conditions.
A pre-construction report commissioned in March for the project rated the masonry on the north facade of 1321 Flatbush as poor. The mayor said work continued despite a prior inspection report showing cracks in that facade, as reported by the New York Times.
The collapsed building had its own history. It was 96 years old with 98 recorded violations dating to 1972, according to the city's housing agency, 11 of them from the past year.
DOB has issued a new stop-work order stating the site had "unsafe construction operations causing" the collapse, and the mayor said DOB is sweeping about 100 other sites tied to five entities associated with the project. A forensic engineer told Realtor.com that determining fault will be a yearslong investigation.
Why it matters for property managers
Lot-line construction is routine in dense cities. The president of a civil engineering firm told Construction Dive that hundreds of other sites in the city have similar work underway, and that if the excavation support "were to fail or not do what it was supposed to do," a neighboring building would fall into the hole the way this one did. The investigation will decide what happened here. The lesson for owners does not depend on the verdict: when the lot next door is being dug out, your building's safety depends partly on someone else's engineering and partly on your own building's condition.
New York City's 2022 Building Code puts most of the protection duty on the party doing the work. A DOB training presentation on the code summarizes the main points (it is a summary, not the law itself, so confirm details against the current code):
- Adjoining property and the people on it must be protected during construction and demolition. When a project needs access to the neighbor's property, the developer must give written notice at least 60 days before work starts, covering the schedule, inspections, monitoring and protection to be installed.
- Crossing the property line requires a license agreement with the adjoining owner. DOB notes that Section 881 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law is another option.
- The party causing an excavation must support the adjoining structure's vertical and lateral loads when digging below its foundation, through shoring, underpinning or bracing.
- During excavation, monitoring is required for buildings within a horizontal distance equal to the depth of the excavation, and for historic structures within 90 feet of the project lot lines. DOB can order monitoring if a potential hazard exists.
- Certain demolitions require an assessment of adjoining bearing-masonry or wood-framed buildings by a registered design professional.
That framework only works if the adjoining owner engages. Notices get ignored, license negotiations stall, and monitoring reports go to the developer's engineer unless you ask for them. Meanwhile, the code does not relieve you of maintaining your own facade, walls and systems. An older building with open violations is a weaker partner in any excavation next door, and a harder position to defend afterward.
Outside New York, adjoining-property rules vary widely by city and state. Check your local building code and ask counsel before assuming the protections above apply where you operate.
What to do this week
- List every building you manage that shares a lot line with active or permitted demolition, excavation or new foundations. In New York City, DOB's public permit records show filings by address. Elsewhere, use your local building department's permit lookup.
- Pull the paperwork for each one. Find any neighbor notices, access or license agreements, pre-construction surveys and monitoring plans. If you never received them, ask the developer in writing for the monitoring plan, its movement thresholds and the reports to date.
- Get your own baseline. Date-stamped photos and video of party walls, facades, basements and cracks before work starts or progresses. For older masonry buildings, consider having your own engineer review the developer's survey and support-of-excavation plan.
- Clear your own open violations, starting with facade, structural, electrical and fire-protection items. Pull your HPD and DOB violation history this week and schedule the repairs.
- Call your insurance broker. Ask how your policy responds to damage caused by adjacent construction, and whether you should require the developer to carry specific coverage or name you as additional insured in any license agreement. Have counsel review the agreement before you sign.
- Tell residents what to report. New or widening cracks, doors or windows that suddenly stick, falling debris and unusual vibration should go to management the same day. Anyone who sees signs of imminent danger should call 911 first.
What we're watching
- DOB's findings on the cause of the collapse and on the jobsite's compliance with its permits and support-of-excavation plan.
- Results of the sweeps of about 100 related sites, and whether DOB widens enforcement to other lot-line excavations.
- Any City Council or DOB proposals to tighten neighbor notice, monitoring or stop-work enforcement after the collapse.
- Insurer and lender reactions for older buildings next to active development sites.