The biggest apartment landlords in the country are making their money on residents who stay, not on new ones. In third-quarter 2026 results, renewal rates rose 5.3% at Essex, MAA and Vivmark and 3.6% at Camden, while new lease rates fell at four of the five REITs, as deep as 6.0% at MAA. If your renewal pricing still follows the asking-rent chart, this is the quarter to rethink it.
What happened
RealPage's third-quarter REIT review, published Nov. 12, compared results from Camden, Essex, MAA, UDR and Vivmark, the company formed when AvalonBay and Equity Residential merged. The pattern held across the group: renewals carried pricing, and new leases dragged at four of the five.
- Renewals. MAA reported renewal lease growth of 5.3%, up 80 basis points from a year earlier, alongside a blended rate (new and renewal combined) of just 0.4%.
- New leases. New lease rates ranged from -6.0% at MAA to -0.2% at Essex. Vivmark was the only one in positive territory, up 0.4%.
- Retention. UDR said its 52% resident retention was an all-time third-quarter high, 370 basis points above a year earlier. MAA reported trailing-12-month turnover of 39.6% and a record-low 10.1% of move-outs tied to buying a single-family home.
- The gap. MAA said the dollar difference between new and renewal rents has held at about $190 to $200 for four quarters, which RealPage described as small next to the cost and hassle of moving.
The national data points the same way. Effective asking rents rose 1.7% year over year in October, the biggest annual gain since May 2023, but they fell 0.7% during the month, the first monthly cut of 2026. RealPage said the annual figure improved mostly because weak months dropped out of the comparison, not because pricing was strong.
Why it matters for property managers
Your residents are worth more than your asking rent suggests. When a REIT's new leases sign 6% below the prior lease while renewals sign 5% above it, the cheapest unit to fill is the one that never goes vacant. That math holds for a 20-unit owner too: a turn costs make-ready, marketing, and vacant days, and at four of these five REITs the replacement lease signed below the prior one.
Concessions are setting your competition's price, not the sticker. Camden's CEO said concessions have stayed "remarkably sticky", and Camden and MAA attributed their new-lease weakness largely to lease-up discounting and lease mix. MAA also said its year-to-date new lease decline narrows to -1.9% when you only count units where the departing resident stayed a single lease term, a figure it treats as a better read on market rent. That suggests part of the headline weakness reflects which leases turned over, not only where the market is.
Geography is doing most of the work. RealPage's October data shows San Francisco rents up 14.7% and San Antonio down 2.6%. UDR's new lease rates rose 5.7% in its West region and fell 7.2% in its Southwest region. A national renewal increase is not a plan; your submarket's numbers are.
Local rules can hit revenue directly. Camden attributed most of its Denver revenue decline to local legislation that stopped it from billing residents for common-area utilities, on top of concessions. Utility pass-throughs, fee caps and rent limits vary by city and state, so a line item that works in one market may not be allowed in the next.
Supply relief is real but uneven. Developers completed nearly 318,000 units in the past year while renters absorbed nearly 304,800 in the year ending in the third quarter, which RealPage described as supply and demand edging closer to balance. MAA said October new-resident pricing improved from September, "counter to the normal seasonal pattern." That is one company's early read, not a market turn, but it is worth tracking in your own leasing.
What to do this week
- Split your rent roll into renewal and new-lease trade-outs. For the last 90 days, calculate the change on renewals and on new leases separately. A single blended number hides exactly what the REITs are reporting.
- Price renewals off your real cost of a turn. Add make-ready, marketing, leasing fees and expected vacant days at today's effective rent. If that number exceeds the extra dollars a bigger renewal increase would bring in, a moderate increase that keeps the resident is usually the better trade.
- Measure your own gap. Compare your average renewal rent to the net effective rent (after concessions) on your latest new leases. MAA's $190 to $200 gap is a useful benchmark; if yours is far wider, expect more move-outs at renewal.
- Look at your expiration calendar for 2027. UDR said it shifted about 25% of its fourth-quarter expirations into higher-demand months a year ago and now has around 15% of leases expiring in the fourth quarter. When you set lease terms on new leases and renewals now, steer expirations away from winter where your local rules allow.
- Audit fees and utility billing by jurisdiction. Before you rely on utility reimbursement or other charges in your 2027 budget, check your city and state rules; confirm with local counsel where they are unclear.
- Check notice requirements before sending increases. Renewal notice periods and any local rent-increase limits vary. Confirm your state's statute and any local ordinance before letters go out.
What we're watching
- Fourth-quarter blends. UDR expects 1.5% to 2% blended lease growth in the fourth quarter and said blends usually drop about 200 basis points from the third quarter to the fourth. Whether operators hold that range is the clearest early read on 2027 pricing power.
- Sun Belt new leases. Camden and MAA lowered full-year same-store revenue guidance while Essex, UDR and Vivmark raised theirs. RealPage framed the key question as whether easing supply turns into firmer Sun Belt revenue.
- Room to run on the coasts. Essex estimated Northern California rents could rise more than 20%, assuming no wage growth, before rent-to-income ratios returned to pre-COVID levels. That is a company estimate with a stated assumption, not a forecast to plan around.
- November rent data. After October's 0.7% monthly cut, the next national readings will show whether the annual gain keeps building or stalls.