---
title: "NY DHCR Fact Sheet 40 update: rent concessions vs. preferential rents explained"
description: "DHCR now says rent concessions can be distinct from preferential rents, undercutting a wave of overcharge suits against rent-stabilized and 421a owners. Pending cases continue, and each concession's documented facts will decide outcomes."
date: 2026-11-20
updated: 2026-11-20
author: "Proppely Research Desk"
kind: NEWS_BRIEF
tags: ["rent-control", "policy", "multifamily", "property-taxes", "new-york"]
reading_minutes: 5
word_count: 1025
canonical: "https://www.proppely.com/insights/ny-dhcr-fact-sheet-40-rent-concessions-preferential-rents"
html: "https://www.proppely.com/insights/ny-dhcr-fact-sheet-40-rent-concessions-preferential-rents"
feed: "https://proppely.com/insights/feed.xml"
license: "Free to read and cite with a link to the canonical URL."
sources:
  - title: "DHCR Clarifies That Rent Concessions Are Not Preferential Rents"
    url: "https://kuckermarino.com/dhcr-clarifies-that-rent-concessions-are-not-preferential-rents/"
    publisher: "Kucker Marino Winiarsky & Bittens"
    published: "2026-11-15"
  - title: "DHCR updated its guidance on preferential rents, rent concessions after rush of lawsuits"
    url: "https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/"
    publisher: "The Real Deal"
    published: "2026-11-17"
  - title: "New City Guidance Could Kill Rent Overcharge Lawsuits"
    url: "https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits"
    publisher: "Bisnow"
    published: "2026-11-16"
  - title: "New York Rent Regulation Guidance Reopens Legal Defense for Concessions"
    url: "https://propmodo.com/new-york-rent-regulation-guidance-reopens-legal-defense-for-concessions/"
    publisher: "Propmodo"
    published: "2026-11-18"
---

# NY DHCR Fact Sheet 40 update: rent concessions vs. preferential rents explained

> DHCR now says rent concessions can be distinct from preferential rents, undercutting a wave of overcharge suits against rent-stabilized and 421a owners. Pending cases continue, and each concession's documented facts will decide outcomes.

## Key takeaways

- New York's DHCR updated Fact Sheet 40 in November 2026 to say it continues to recognize distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents.
- The change targets confusion from a 2019 edit that fueled at least 21 overcharge suits covering more than 24 properties and 12,000 units, per Adler & Stachenfeld.
- The update is guidance, not a court ruling: pending suits continue, and DHCR says each case is fact-specific.
- Whether a concession is a preferential rent turns on facts at signing, such as building conditions, occupancy and concession length, landlord counsel say.
- Owners should document the business reason behind every post-2019 concession on stabilized and 421a units now.

New York's housing agency has rewritten the guidance at the center of a wave of rent-overcharge suits against owners of rent-stabilized buildings. In an update to Fact Sheet 40 [published Nov. 16, 2026](https://kuckermarino.com/dhcr-clarifies-that-rent-concessions-are-not-preferential-rents/), the Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) says it "continues to recognize" distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents. The suits it bears on involve [at least 21 cases, more than 24 properties and 12,000 units](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/), according to law firm Adler & Stachenfeld.

The update does not end the litigation. It changes what tenants' lawyers have to prove, and it makes the paper trail behind each concession you granted far more important.

## What happened

The dispute comes from 2019. The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act, [signed June 14, 2019](https://kuckermarino.com/dhcr-clarifies-that-rent-concessions-are-not-preferential-rents/), requires an owner charging less than the legal regulated rent (a "preferential rent") to keep offering that lower rent on renewal, raised only by the guideline increase or a DHCR-approved increase. Several months later, DHCR removed an example from Fact Sheet 40 that had distinguished concessions from preferential rents, [without explanation](https://kuckermarino.com/dhcr-clarifies-that-rent-concessions-are-not-preferential-rents/).

Before that, DHCR had treated a concession as distinct from a preferential rent when the free period [did not exceed three months and the tenant paid the full monthly rent for the rest of the lease](https://kuckermarino.com/dhcr-clarifies-that-rent-concessions-are-not-preferential-rents/), according to Kucker Marino Winiarsky & Bittens. Many owners kept granting free months after 2019 and set renewal increases off the full lease rent, not the discounted net effective rent, [per The Real Deal](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/).

Tenants' lawyers argued that those concessions were really preferential rents, so every renewal priced off the full rent was an overcharge. Courts gave that argument weight, starting with a Manhattan trial-court decision known as Grey, [per Bisnow](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits), and several appellate decisions treated the 2019 edit as a change of guidance for post-HSTPA concessions, [per Kucker Marino](https://kuckermarino.com/dhcr-clarifies-that-rent-concessions-are-not-preferential-rents/). Suits followed: one firm filed [21 such suits between August and early November](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits), according to Adler & Stachenfeld data cited by Bisnow, and one suit claims AvalonBay overcharged Downtown Brooklyn tenants by [at least $40 million](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/). The targets have centered on 421a buildings, where even market-rate units can be rent-regulated during the abatement period, and Adler & Stachenfeld counts [$1 billion in 421a tax credits](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/) received by the buildings involved.

The revised fact sheet now states that DHCR's 2019 modification "was not intended to indicate the contrary," [as quoted by The Real Deal](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/). A DHCR spokesperson added that each case is fact-specific and the agency will not pre-judge whether any particular concession is lawful.

## Why it matters for property managers

**The burden shifts to the facts.** Landlord attorney Matthew Brett of Belkin Burden Goldman said whether a concession counts as a preferential rent depends on the circumstances when the lease was signed, such as building conditions, occupancy and how long the concession lasted, [per The Real Deal](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/). Another defense attorney told Bisnow that plaintiffs will now [have to show the reasons for a concession did not exist](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits) when it was offered. That is a prediction from counsel, not a ruling.

**Pending suits are not dismissed.** Courts still have to decide how to apply the clarified guidance to individual cases, [Propmodo notes](https://propmodo.com/new-york-rent-regulation-guidance-reopens-legal-defense-for-concessions/), and one attorney told Bisnow he "very highly" doubts open litigation [will stop](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits). The fact sheet is agency guidance, not a statute or a court order.

**421a exposure stays larger.** In suits against 421a buildings, plaintiffs claim they can seek the property-tax benefits the owner received, not just the alleged overpayment, which raises the stakes compared with buildings that only carry rent-stabilized units, [according to Adler & Stachenfeld's Zachary Nathanson](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits).

**Concessions are still a live tool, carefully.** Owners often grant free months during lease-up, when a building's amenities aren't available yet, or in the slower winter leasing season, [per Bisnow](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits). The update suggests a concession tied to a documented reason can be defended. It does not say every concession is safe, and the agency said it would not pre-judge any case.

**Outside New York, the lesson travels.** Any regulated program that caps renewal increases off a base rent can turn a concession into a pricing question. If you manage affordable, tax-credit or locally rent-controlled units elsewhere, confirm with local counsel which rent your program treats as the base.

## What to do this week

1. **Inventory every concession granted on a rent-stabilized or 421a unit since June 2019.** List the unit, lease dates, free period, and the lease rent used as the base for each renewal.
2. **Rebuild the "why" file for each one.** Pull what existed at signing: lease-up occupancy reports, construction schedules, amenity delays, market comps. Mr. Brett's comments point to these facts as the ones that matter.
3. **Check lease and rider language.** Confirm each concession was written as a temporary discount on a stated lease rent, and how the renewal base was described. Have counsel review anything ambiguous.
4. **If you are already named in a suit, send the update to your litigation counsel today.** Ask whether it supports a motion or a request to revisit prior rulings in your case.
5. **Set a rule for new concessions.** Before granting free rent on a stabilized unit, record the business reason, the occupancy at the time and the term, and have it reviewed against current DHCR guidance.
6. **Flag it for owners and lenders.** Uncertainty here had [already begun affecting underwriting](https://propmodo.com/new-york-rent-regulation-guidance-reopens-legal-defense-for-concessions/). Give owners and lenders a short note on your exposure and the documentation you hold.

## What we're watching

- **How courts treat the update.** Landlord attorney Nativ Winiarsky said the word "continues" likely bodes well for asking courts to reconsider decisions such as Grey, [per The Real Deal](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/). The first rulings that cite the revised fact sheet will show whether it carries weight.
- **The pace of new filings.** Mr. Nathanson told Bisnow he wonders whether the update [slows down the seeming acceleration of new cases](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits).
- **Further DHCR detail.** DHCR says concessions may still count as preferential rents in some contexts, and one attorney said the new guidance [leaves some ambiguity](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits) about those conditions. Any further agency guidance or a legislative fix would change the analysis.

This is general information, not legal advice. Rent-regulation outcomes turn on each lease's facts; confirm with New York counsel before changing renewal pricing on a regulated unit.

## FAQ

**What did DHCR change in Fact Sheet 40?**

In a version published Nov. 16, 2026, DHCR states it continues to recognize distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents and that its 2019 edit was not intended to indicate otherwise ([Kucker Marino](https://kuckermarino.com/dhcr-clarifies-that-rent-concessions-are-not-preferential-rents/)).

**Does the Fact Sheet 40 update end rent concession overcharge lawsuits?**

No. DHCR says each case is fact-specific and it will not pre-judge whether a concession is lawful, and courts must still decide how to apply the guidance ([The Real Deal](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/)).

**How many rent concession lawsuits have been filed in New York?**

At least 21 suits involving more than 24 properties, 12,000 units and $1 billion in 421a tax credits, according to Adler & Stachenfeld as reported by [The Real Deal](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/).

**Can New York landlords still offer free rent on rent-stabilized units?**

The update suggests a concession tied to documented circumstances at signing can be defended, but it is not a blanket approval. Record the reason, occupancy and term, and confirm with New York counsel before granting one.

## Sources

1. [DHCR Clarifies That Rent Concessions Are Not Preferential Rents](https://kuckermarino.com/dhcr-clarifies-that-rent-concessions-are-not-preferential-rents/) — Kucker Marino Winiarsky & Bittens
2. [DHCR updated its guidance on preferential rents, rent concessions after rush of lawsuits](https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2026/11/18/landlords-receive-second-change-after-dhcr-rule-40-change/) — The Real Deal
3. [New City Guidance Could Kill Rent Overcharge Lawsuits](https://www.bisnow.com/news/new-york/affordable-housing/new-city-guidance-could-kill-rent-overcharge-lawsuits) — Bisnow
4. [New York Rent Regulation Guidance Reopens Legal Defense for Concessions](https://propmodo.com/new-york-rent-regulation-guidance-reopens-legal-defense-for-concessions/) — Propmodo

---
Published by the Proppely Research Desk. Canonical: https://www.proppely.com/insights/ny-dhcr-fact-sheet-40-rent-concessions-preferential-rents
