---
title: "Rates must hit 5.5% for a home loan payment to match rent: what it means for renewals"
description: "RealPage finds owning a median home, with taxes and insurance, costs about $930 a month more than average rent, and 57% of renters renewed in Q3. With Freddie Mac's 30-year rate at 7.18%, expect high retention, but price renewals against your submarket."
date: 2026-11-09
updated: 2026-11-09
author: "Proppely Research Desk"
kind: MARKET_TREND
tags: ["multifamily", "mortgage-rates", "home-prices", "rent-growth", "vacancy"]
reading_minutes: 4
word_count: 845
canonical: "https://www.proppely.com/insights/mortgage-rates-5-5-percent-buying-matches-rent-renewals"
html: "https://www.proppely.com/insights/mortgage-rates-5-5-percent-buying-matches-rent-renewals"
feed: "https://proppely.com/insights/feed.xml"
license: "Free to read and cite with a link to the canonical URL."
sources:
  - title: "The math behind staying put: When does buying a home beat renting?"
    url: "https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/"
    publisher: "RealPage"
    published: "2026-11-01"
  - title: "Annual rent growth sees a milestone, even as prices ease in October"
    url: "https://www.realpage.com/analytics/october-2026-us-data-update/"
    publisher: "RealPage"
    published: "2026-11-05"
  - title: "Mortgage Rates (Primary Mortgage Market Survey)"
    url: "https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms"
    publisher: "Freddie Mac"
    published: "2026-11-04"
---

# Rates must hit 5.5% for a home loan payment to match rent: what it means for renewals

> RealPage finds owning a median home, with taxes and insurance, costs about $930 a month more than average rent, and 57% of renters renewed in Q3. With Freddie Mac's 30-year rate at 7.18%, expect high retention, but price renewals against your submarket.

## Key takeaways

- RealPage estimates mortgage rates would need to fall to about 5.5% for the loan payment on a median home to match average apartment rent.
- Including property taxes and insurance, owning a median home costs about $930 a month more than average rent, per RealPage.
- 57% of renters with leases expiring in Q3 2026 renewed, up from 46% in 2006, and renewal terms are the longest RealPage has recorded since 2002.
- Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.18% on Nov. 5, 2026, down from 7.24% a week earlier but up from 6.22% a year ago.
- High retention lowers turnover costs, but renewal increases still need to be tested against falling rents in some Sun Belt markets.

Owning a median-priced home now costs about [$930 a month more than the average apartment rent](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/) once property taxes and insurance are included, according to a new RealPage analysis. By RealPage's math, mortgage rates would have to fall to [about 5.5%](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/) before the loan payment alone matches rent, and Freddie Mac's 30-year average was still [7.18% on Nov. 5](https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms). For landlords, that gap is the main reason residents are renewing more and staying longer.

## What happened

RealPage compared the monthly payment on a median-priced home (30-year fixed, 20% down) with average apartment rent at five points since 2000. Today the principal-and-interest payment runs [about $2,300, roughly 20% above the $1,915 average rent](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/) in its data. Even near the 2006 housing peak, the payment ran only [about 16% above rent](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/).

Add national-average property taxes and insurance and the full cost of owning reaches [about $2,840 a month](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/). On that all-in basis, RealPage puts the break-even mortgage rate at [about 2.7%](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/), close to the pandemic-era record low. If rates stay put instead, the median home price would have to fall to [about $351,000, roughly 16% below today](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/), for the loan payment to match rent.

Renters are acting on that math. In RealPage data, [57% of renters with leases expiring in the third quarter of 2026 renewed, versus 46% in 2006](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/), and the average renewal term is now a little over 12 months, the longest RealPage has recorded since 2002. The Northeast leads, with [64% of residents renewing in the third quarter](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/).

Rates have eased a bit since RealPage ran its numbers. Freddie Mac's 30-year average slipped from [7.24% on Oct. 29 to 7.18% on Nov. 5](https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms), but that is still nearly a point above the [6.22% of a year earlier](https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms).

## Why it matters for property managers

**Retention is doing the heavy lifting.** RealPage's October numbers show rents [fell 0.7% in the month](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/october-2026-us-data-update/), the first monthly cut of 2026, and occupancy eased to [95%](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/october-2026-us-data-update/). RealPage notes that when fewer residents move out to buy, occupancy holds up better. That buys you fewer turns, fewer vacant days and lower make-ready spend.

**The escape valve depends on where you operate.** RealPage estimates the break-even rate is [about 6% in the Midwest, where the median home sells for about $330,000](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/), but [about 4% in the West, where the median price tops $610,000](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/). A Midwest portfolio is much closer to losing residents to ownership if rates drop than a West Coast one is. Note that the 6% figure covers the loan payment only, not taxes and insurance.

**Staying is not the same as paying more.** Residents who can't afford to buy are also stretched on rent. A renewal increase that is out of line with your submarket can push a resident to a cheaper apartment instead of a house. In October, rents were still falling year over year in markets such as [Houston (-1.8%), Tampa (-1%) and Denver (-0.8%)](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/october-2026-us-data-update/), so new-lease competition is real in parts of the Sun Belt and Mountain West even while national renewal rates are high.

**This is an analysis, not a forecast.** RealPage's break-even figures assume 20% down and national-average taxes and insurance, and leave out maintenance and tax deductions. Use them to frame your thinking, not as a prediction for any single property.

## What to do this week

1. **Pull your own renewal rate and average renewal term by property for the last two quarters.** Compare them with RealPage's [57% national renewal rate](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/). If you are well below it, look at service and pricing before blaming the housing market.
2. **Price renewals against your submarket, not against "nowhere else to go."** High retention gives you room for modest increases, but test each offer against current new-lease asking rents and concessions nearby.
3. **Offer longer terms where they fit your expiration schedule.** Residents are already choosing longer leases. Use 13- to 15-month options to steer move-outs away from your slow leasing months.
4. **Rebudget turnover for 2027.** If your move-outs are trending down, cut make-ready and vacancy-loss assumptions to match your actual data, and shift some of that budget to retention work such as maintenance response times.
5. **Set a rate alert.** RealPage flags [5.5%](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/) as the first milestone. Track Freddie Mac's weekly average, and if it moves toward 6% and you operate in lower-priced markets, plan for the possibility of more move-outs to ownership.

## What we're watching

- **The 10-year Treasury.** RealPage notes mortgage rates track the 10-year more closely than the Fed's rate, and that the 10-year has eased from [above 5.3% in early October to about 5%](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/) while mortgage rates stayed above 7%.
- **Freddie Mac's weekly survey.** A sustained move under 7% would be the first step toward the break-even zone, not arrival at it.
- **Home prices.** Even modest declines, combined with income growth, narrow the gap over time. RealPage estimates it would take [about eight years of typical income growth](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/) at today's prices and rates for the payment to fall back to 25% of median income.
- **Renewal and lease-length data.** If both keep rising, residents are settling in for the long haul, and your 2027 plan should assume it.

## FAQ

**What mortgage rate would make buying a home as cheap as renting?**

RealPage estimates the 30-year rate would need to fall to about 5.5% for the loan payment on a median-priced home to match average apartment rent. Including property taxes and insurance, the break-even rate drops to about 2.7%.

**How many renters are renewing their leases in 2026?**

In RealPage data, 57% of renters whose leases expired in the third quarter of 2026 renewed, compared with 46% in 2006. The Northeast led at 64%.

**What is the current 30-year mortgage rate?**

Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.18% as of Nov. 5, 2026, down from 7.24% the week before and up from 6.22% a year earlier.

## Sources

1. [The math behind staying put: When does buying a home beat renting?](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/the-math-behind-staying-put-when-does-buying-a-home-beat-renting/) — RealPage
2. [Annual rent growth sees a milestone, even as prices ease in October](https://www.realpage.com/analytics/october-2026-us-data-update/) — RealPage
3. [Mortgage Rates (Primary Mortgage Market Survey)](https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms) — Freddie Mac

---
Published by the Proppely Research Desk. Canonical: https://www.proppely.com/insights/mortgage-rates-5-5-percent-buying-matches-rent-renewals
